What would another withdrawal cost?
Baseline versus one scenario — incremental federal tax, newly taxable Social Security in dollars, and the Medicare premium effect two years ahead. English and Español from the same engine.
Retirement Withdrawal & Tax Planner
If I withdraw or convert more, what changes in my taxes and future Medicare premiums? Baseline versus one scenario — federal only, 2026 figures.
Privacy: your numbers stay in this browser’s memory. Nothing is saved or sent to GTQ. Press Clear when you finish. No names, SSNs, dates of birth, or account numbers.
First, a short scope check
Does any of this apply: self-employment income, investment losses or collectibles, an early-distribution penalty, foreign income or exclusions, a prior-year Social Security lump sum, or Marketplace (ACA) coverage for anyone in the household?
The change you are considering
One scenario at a time — a withdrawal and a conversion are never added together here.
What would another withdrawal cost?
| Baseline | |
|---|---|
| Taxable Social Security | $0 |
| Adjusted gross income | $0 |
| Deduction used (standard) | $16,100 |
| Enhanced senior deduction | $0 |
| Taxable income | $0 |
| Regular income tax | $0 |
| — of that, tax on qualified dividends/gains | $0 |
| Net investment income tax (3.8%) | $0 |
| Total modeled federal tax | $0 |
Federal 2026 estimates for the ordinary case: no state tax, no EITC, no AMT, no itemized-limitation modeling, no ACA subsidy reconciliation, no IRA basis/pro-rata, no RMD or QCD computations, no claiming optimization, no lifetime projections. Excluded effects are flagged, not guessed. General information, not tax or legal advice.
Why the second dollar costs more
The hidden couplings in a retirement return.
- Social Security taxability. Between $25,000–$34,000 of provisional income (single), each added dollar makes 50 cents of benefits taxable; above that, up to 85 cents. The withdrawal is taxed and it drags benefits with it.
- Senior deduction phaseout. The enhanced deduction falls 6 cents per dollar of MAGI over $75,000 (single) / $150,000 (joint) — another quiet marginal cost near the thresholds.
- IRMAA cliffs two years out. Cross a MAGI threshold by $1 and the whole household surcharge jumps a tier — which is why the planner computes exact headroom to the next tier, including the Social Security effect.
- Qualified dividends stack. Preferential-rate income is taxed on top of ordinary income — a withdrawal can push gains from the 0% band into 15%, or 15% into 20%.
Common questions
How much tax will an extra retirement withdrawal cost?
It depends on everything else on your return — not just the withdrawal. A withdrawal can push more of your Social Security into taxable income (up to 85%), reduce the enhanced senior deduction as MAGI rises, and expose investment income to the 3.8% NIIT. This planner computes the baseline and the withdrawal year in full and shows the true incremental federal tax, then translates it into spendable cash.
Why does my tax go up faster than the withdrawal itself?
Because of Social Security taxability: each dollar of extra income can pull up to 85 cents of benefits into taxable income, so the marginal base is larger than the withdrawal. The planner recalculates taxable benefits for both the baseline and the scenario and explains the difference in dollars — the "additional-tax rate" it shows is the effective rate on the gross withdrawal.
Will a Roth conversion raise my Medicare premiums?
Usually, two years later. Medicare uses a two-year MAGI lookback, so a 2026 conversion affects 2028 premiums. Because 2028 tables are not published yet, this planner shows a clearly labeled illustration using 2026 thresholds held constant — never presented as official 2028 amounts. It also estimates how much more taxable income fits before the next IRMAA tier, recalculating Social Security taxability at every step.
Withdrawal or Roth conversion — which is modeled?
One at a time, never both added together. For a withdrawal, the planner shows spendable cash (gross minus incremental tax). For a conversion, it shows the amount moved to Roth and the estimated tax separately — converted money is not spendable cash, and the estimate assumes the tax is paid from funds outside the conversion. Conversions cannot include RMD amounts; the planner makes you confirm that.
What is not included?
State tax, EITC, AMT, IRA basis and pro-rata calculations, RMD and QCD computations, ACA subsidy effects, capital-loss netting, collectibles and unrecaptured §1250 gains, early-distribution penalties, and lifetime projections. When a short scope check flags any of these, the combined "total cost" figure is hidden rather than presented as complete — excluded effects are disclosed, never guessed.